ShoutWire TV

50

Shouts

Shout it

0

Bashes

Bash it

Protecting Torture: The Red Cross' Deadly Silence  

   Posted by carlosdamackeral  Promoted 1334 days 3 hours ago  865 views   

    Politics / Law - Justice  |   Comments 13 comments  | 

  • Stumble it!
  • Facebook

By promising confidentiality to the occupying and imprisoning powers the International Committee of the Red Cross monitors the fate of prisoners of war that no other organization can reach — from Guantanamo Bay’s Camp X-ray, to Abu Ghraib and even the many Israeli detention centers in occupied Palestine. Here, Rafeef Ziadah questions whether the ICRC’s monitoring efforts help prisoners or protect those who violate prisoners’ human rights.





Comments

These comments in RSS.
Comment View Threshold:
wizzler, on 7/26/2006 9:08:50 AM
Total Posts: 45, Joined: 5/30/2006
how credible is something from a website called the LEFTturn.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
warvigilent, on 7/26/2006 9:21:00 AM
Total Posts: 1002, Joined: 1/13/2006
^ too bad you can find this stuff all over huh. the red cross isnt the first aid organisation that had to sign confidentially crap in order to see prisoners. and they have been one of the many who protest against the crimes commited.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
avatar
yasinumur, on 7/26/2006 10:11:01 AM
Total Posts: 901, Joined: 5/3/2006
Don't you trust the website? = Do your own research
Need help? = just in 5 secs.
http://news.google.ca/news?q=red+cross+attacked+by+israel&hl=en
&lr=&sa=X&oi=news&ct=title
http://www.smh.com.au/news/world/ambulance
s-fired-on-by-israel-says-red-cross/2006/07/24/1153593272695.html
htt
p://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,251-2282992,00.html
http://sumou
d.tao.ca/?q=node/view/76
http://www.counterpunch.org/ess05232006.html

http://www.petitiononline.com/dcips/petition.html
http://peacepales
tine.blogspot.com/2005/03/palestinian-political-prisoners-some.html
h
ttp://www.ifamericansknew.org/stats/prisoners.html
http://www.addamee
r.org/paprisoners/

Want more? = Do it yourself fucking lazy.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
Acervartan, on 7/26/2006 2:39:55 PM
Total Posts: 35, Joined: 7/16/2006
The Red Cross have a long history of silence. During WWII they would not speak out against violence of the Nazi concentration and death camps.

Some people support this concept of access for silence, but ask yourself, who does it serve? Do prisoners really benefit because they might get to see a ICRC doctor once or twice a year, does that compensate for beatings, torture or the isolation from their families and legal assistance. No, the Red Cross get lots of money for its work and its complicency with gov'ts. If it spoke out, it would lose funding and see its organization shrink.

Other NGOs such as MSF (doctors without borders), have the integrety to speak out and being attention to situations people know nothing about, and it costs them, sometimes they are arrested other times they can be kicked out of the country. In some cases MSF people are killed. However, as Abu Ghraib incident showed, only when a real effort is made to expose abuse is there ever any move towards ending it.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
avatar
kfk, on 7/26/2006 4:49:49 PM
Total Posts: 91, Joined: 3/17/2006
@Acervartan: You said that the Red Cross is an "NGO," (Non-Governmental Organisation for those who don't know) but that's not quite true--check it out:

"People who think of the Red Cross as a "private charity" would be shocked to discover its actual legal status.

Congress incorporated the Red Cross to act under "government supervision." Eight of the 50 members of its board of governors are appointed by the president of the United States, who also serves as honorary chairperson. Currently, the Secretaries of State and Homeland Security are members of the board of governors.

This unique, quasi-governmental status allows the Red Cross to purchase supplies from the military and use government facilities--military personnel can actually be assigned to duty with the Red Cross. Last year, the organization received $60 million in grants from federal and state governments. However, as one federal court noted, "A perception that the organization is independent and neutral is equally vital."

The leading administrators and officials of the Red Cross are almost always drawn from the corporate boardroom or the military high command. Among the past chairs and presidents of the Red Cross are seven former generals or admirals and one ex-president.

The current president Marty Evans is a retired rear admiral and a director of the investment firm Lehman Brothers Holdings. Bonnie McElveen-Hunter, the chair of the Red Cross, is also CEO of Pace Communications, whose clients include United Airlines, Delta Air Lines and AT&T--a group of companies known for their vicious treatment of workers.

The Red Cross has become particularly tied up with the Republican Party in recent decades. Both McElveen-Hunter and Evans are Bush appointees--for her part, McElveen-Hunter has donated over $130,000 to the Republican Party since 2000.

* * *

THOUGH IT is technically a nonprofit, the Red Cross is run more like profit-hungry corporation than what most people think a "charity" would act like. The most deadly example of this was the Red Cross' criminally negligent response to the early stages of the AIDS epidemic in the 1980s.

The Red Cross has been for many decades, and remains today, the largest blood bank in the country. In 1982 and especially 1983, when it would have possible to contain the outbreak--or at least stop the spread of the disease through infusions of infected blood--major blood banks, led by the Red Cross, opposed national testing of blood for HIV.

The Red Cross' opposition was based on the financial cost. As investigative journalist Judith Reitman wrote in her book Bad Blood: "It appeared it would be cheaper to pay off infected blood recipients, should they pursue legal action, than to up the Red Cross blood supply."

Earlier this year, the Canadian Red Cross pleaded guilty to distributing contaminated blood supplies that infected thousands of Canadians with HIV and hepatitis C in the 1980s. This scandal is a large part of why the Canadian Red Cross was removed from running the country's blood supply in the late 1990s--but not the American Red Cross."
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
techapoc, on 7/26/2006 5:15:05 PM
Total Posts: 7, Joined: 7/26/2006
Those fucking muslims should be torture and killed there no good for this world anyways.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
Acervartan, on 7/26/2006 6:54:00 PM
Total Posts: 36, Joined: 7/16/2006
Great post kfk, but I didnt intend to say RC was an NGO, I said "other NGOs such as MSF", but I guess that wasnt very good english. You are right, and I tried to convey, that the RC is driven by the money it receives, rather than by any humanitarian mandate. Your examples are good, but I think the over-solicitation of donations for events such as 911, the Tsunami and Katrina, where millions was taken from people despite there being no way to use it for anything, shows their total lack of integrety. Millions collected sit in RC accounts collecting interest.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
avatar
doomsayer, on 7/26/2006 7:04:03 PM
Total Posts: 17, Joined: 7/24/2006
"Those fucking muslims should be torture and killed there no good for this world anyways."

Asians too because I think they stink. Muslims though are cool. They get good bud.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
avatar
RiotHero, on 7/26/2006 7:33:09 PM
Total Posts: 6, Joined: 6/15/2006
So if the red cross is run by high ranking US government officials then why would you expect them to tell on their own?

I say good job red cross. Keep up the good work. Keep helping people and don't become a traitor.
 |  Comment Score: Trash  |  Edit Comment
techapoc, on 7/26/2006 8:16:22 PM
Total Posts: 17, Joined: 7/26/2006
@doomsayer dude Muslims are radical insane sand niggers. The only thing their good for is nothing. We should take there oil and take there money. Dude theres nothing wrong with asains they give great sucky sucky. The only county i dont like is north korea we need to kill those Fascist fuckers. And fuck sand niggers if ur for them u can go down with them.
 |  Comment Score: Neutral  |  Edit Comment
Comments per page: 10

  • 1
  • 2
  • Forward
  • Page 1 of 2

Post your comments

 

Your Message:

This system allows you to use html-like tags in replacement of HTML. These tags are easier to use and are widely supported on messageboard systems.

HTML DISABLED
CODE DISABLED

 

You must be a registered user in order to post comments.
Please sign in or create a new account.

XxoozerobulshoyDockZaWolvenHockeyGodVaMpIrEF00DDeadmanspointJustXquincy0191SteelyDanBebichanReagannodnarb232001LifeRiotFidoAdamnesssailirish7ThisisJeffKhramGodsSontimekeeperRomanov
Shoutwire channels
Worth Calling The Cops For
 0 views
 15 shouts
 0 bashes
posted by GaaaaaH
When You See it
 1 views
 15 shouts
 0 bashes
posted by AliceC
Awesome
 0 views
 15 shouts
 2 bashes
posted by BottleB
Black Friday
 0 views
 16 shouts
 0 bashes
posted by GaaaaaH

FlikThe Beginning (day One)
body { font-family: Arial; font-size: 12px; line-height: 20px; width: 545px; } div.mine p { text-align: justify; } .avat { text-align: center; float: left; margin: 0px; margin-right: 10px; border: 2px solid black; } Date: The Beginning (day one) Current mood: Creative Listening to: Phil Collins - Another Day in Paradise Posted by:THE_ONE After having been harassed interminably by all the other deities, I have finally deigned t...

TigerEyesRobot Unicorn Attack
For those of you aware of what Robot Unicorn Attack is, bear with me. For those of you who don’t, this is for you.Robot Unicorn Attack is a free online flash game from Adult Swim made out of rainbows, unicorns, and crack. This is a severe deviation from the other games the site offers (Pole Dance Hero, Radioactive Teddy Bear Zombies, and Zombie Hooker Nightmare to name a few) and yet it has nearly 10 million more plays than any other game listed.Its popularity...